Nobody starts a business hoping to fire someone. But it happens. And when it does, how you handle it determines whether you move on cleanly or spend the next year dealing with a wrongful termination claim.
This guide covers what you need to know about at-will employment, what it actually protects (and what it doesn't), and how to terminate an employee the right way.
What Is At-Will Employment?
In most U.S. states, employment is "at will." This means either the employer or the employee can end the relationship at any time, for any reason that isn't illegal, with or without notice.
At-will employment gives you flexibility. But it doesn't give you immunity. There are important exceptions.
Discrimination. You cannot terminate someone based on race, color, religion, sex, national origin, age (40+), disability, genetic information, or any other protected characteristic under federal, state, or local law.
Retaliation. You cannot fire someone for filing a workers' comp claim, reporting a safety violation, filing a discrimination complaint, requesting FMLA leave, or engaging in any other legally protected activity.
Breach of contract. If you have a written employment contract, offer letter, or handbook that creates an implied contract (e.g., "employees will only be terminated for cause"), that overrides at-will status.
Public policy violations. You cannot fire someone for refusing to do something illegal, for jury duty, for voting, or for exercising a legal right.
These exceptions are why documentation, consistency, and process matter - even in an at-will state.
Document performance issues in real time. The biggest mistake we see is business owners who decide to fire someone and then scramble to create a paper trail after the fact. That's backwards.
Document issues as they happen: dates, specific behaviors, conversations held, and any corrective actions taken. If you can't point to a documented pattern of performance problems, you're vulnerable.
Follow your own policies. If your employee handbook outlines a progressive discipline process - verbal warning, written warning, final warning, termination - follow it. Courts and agencies look closely at whether you followed your own rules. Deviating from your stated process without a very good reason undermines your position.
Be consistent. If Employee A was fired for chronic tardiness but Employee B has the same pattern and hasn't been disciplined, that inconsistency creates an inference of bias. Whatever standard you set, apply it equally.
Prepare for the conversation. A termination meeting should be brief, respectful, and direct. Have a witness (another manager or HR representative). State the reason clearly and factually. Don't debate or negotiate. Have the final paycheck ready (some states require immediate payment on termination). Collect company property, keys, and access credentials. Provide information about COBRA or benefit continuation.
Know your state's final paycheck rules. This catches many employers off guard. Some states (like California) require you to pay all wages, including accrued PTO, immediately upon termination. Others give you until the next regular payday. Failing to comply can result in waiting-time penalties that add up quickly.
What About PIPs?
A Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) isn't legally required before termination. But it's often a smart step - both for the employee and for your protection. A well-documented PIP shows that you gave the employee a clear opportunity to improve, with specific goals, resources, and a timeline. If they don't improve, the PIP becomes part of your documentation trail. We cover this topic in depth in a separate post later this month.
If the employee is a member of a protected class and might claim discrimination, has recently filed a complaint or requested accommodations, is on or recently returned from leave, has an employment contract, or if you're unsure about anything, it's worth consulting an employment attorney before proceeding.
The cost of a 30-minute legal consultation is trivial compared to the cost of a wrongful termination lawsuit.
Need Support?
Termination is one of the most sensitive HR functions. Having a partner who can guide you through documentation, process, and compliance - before and during the conversation - can make a difficult situation manageable.
That's what we do. Reach out anytime.
mossconsulting.com/book-a-free-consultation