Go Back Up

THE MOSS HR MINUTE | EPISODE 45

Smarter Employee Benefits for Growing Businesses

with JJ Weeks and Zach Rangel, Partners at 19:21 Consultants

November 12, 2026 · 42 min 26 sec

Smarter Employee Benefits for Growing Businesses with JJ Weeks & Zach Rangel
  • 43 min
Smarter Employee Benefits for Growing Businesses with JJ Weeks & Zach Rangel
The Moss HR Minute - Test Import
Play
Read the full transcript

Hey, everyone. I'm Nicole Moss. I'm the co-founder of Moss Consulting HR Services. We help business owners build, manage, and strengthen their teams so that they can focus on what they got into business to do. Welcome back to this edition of The Moss HR Minute. Today I'm sitting down with Zach Rangel and JJ Weeks.

JJ and Zach are partners at 19:21 Consultants, a benefit brokerage based here in Texas that helps businesses build, smarter employee benefit strategies from negotiating rates, to managing compliance, to keeping enrollment simple for HR teams. Uh, Zach and JJ are gonna walk us through what business owners get wrong about their benefits, how rising premiums actually work, and what it really takes to turn benefits into a tool for attracting and keeping great people. Let's get into it. Yeah. So- Awesome ... how this works, I'm gonna ask you five hard-hitting questions. Okay. You have one minute to answer. Okay. Okay? It's very serious. We can do that. All right. And then we'll jump into a discussion afterwards. All right. Okay? Sounds great. So, um, let's go. Question number one. A lot of business owners just renew their benefits year after year- Yep ... um, without asking many questions. Uh, what's the biggest sign that they're overpaying for their premiums or getting maybe a bad deal without realizing it? Sure. Yeah, yeah. No, I think, uh, I think the first thing that we look at whenever we're talking to a prospect or a client is something called a medical loss ratio. Okay. That really is the equation for how groups are underwritten with their premiums, how they get a, an increase or a decrease to their renewal.

And so number one, what they do is they take a very simple equation, how much are we paying claims versus how much we pay in premiums? If that ratio is under 85 to 90%, we should receive a positive renewal. Mm-hmm. If it's well over that, you could see a significant increase. And so with our staff, we wanna make sure that we're looking at what that ratio is and maybe if you're overspending. Um, there's a few other layers deep that you can go with what's causing those, uh, uh, claims to increase. Okay. But that's from a high level, that's usually the equation we look at. Got it. So sometimes you'll hear people say, like, they're running hot, and- Yep ... HR people know that, you guys know that, but business owners are like, "Is that good?" Yeah. And like, typically, that's bad. Yes. Yeah. Talk to me about running hot. That would be bad.

That is bad. You know, uh, yeah, I think Zach's 100% correct on the, on the medical loss ratio, that MLR. That's what you're referring to if we're running hot. Let's say we paid $1 million in, in premiums. Mm-hmm. We, we paid 1.5 million in claims. Our ratio is, you know, 1.5 divided by a million, we're at a 150% ratio. Right. That's hot. That's bad. And that's where a carrier lost half a million dollars last year. Right. And that's why that renewal is gonna be pretty aggressive, 'cause they've got to get their half a million dollars back that they just lost, plus they gotta try to get a margin on, on next year's business.

So that's what running hot is, and- Okay ... you do not want to be running hot.

Right. Um, and to Zach's point, I think, I think sometimes brokers or employers can sometimes ... they just accept that. Well, this was the year we ran hot. Maybe it'll get better the next couple of years. Uh, there's so much strategy there- Yeah ... in what led to you running hot. Was it, uh, was it one or two high claimants?

Are they still employed with you? What's the story behind those high claimants? Is your company growing? Are you shrinking? Um, there's just ... I think the MLR tells half the story. Yeah. I think that's where you have to start, but I think that's where a lot of brokers and employers end. Mm-hmm. There's so many things you can do on the backside of it. Yeah. Yeah. And so you guys, would you say that at renewal time, no matter what, if you've been with the same ... Y- M- Maybe your team has stayed the same, you've got the same broker, it's still worth looking at more than just auto-renewing every year? Oh, non-negotiable. Yeah, 1000%. I think, I think the biggest challenge in kind of what the traditional broker model is set up to do is to check on it once a year- Mm-hmm ... look at it, and it be more of a end result and a reactive approach.

Whereas if you wanna have a long-term, uh, sustainable health insurance plan, you have to be looking at things nine months out, six months out, and monitoring those claims, be able to tell a story to an underwriter of, "Hey, look, we had a shock claim that w- that is not going to be ongoing. That million-dollar claim won't be there next year."

Right. And so trying to be proactive, um, is gonna help to mitigate and lower those renewals year over year.

Love it. Absolutely. Yeah, I mean, I, I ... We talked to a lot of CFOs who are managing- Yeah ... this plan, and one thing we often ask is, "You know, when's the last time you looked at this?"

Right. A lot of them say, "Well, it was, it was last year."

Well, you know, what we find, we start asking some questions, they spend more time analyzing the value of their F-150 they have out in their fleet that gets an oil change- Mm-hmm ... every so many miles, and tires rotated every so many miles. Right. And they've got a regimen on keeping the truck clean and who's gonna mon- I mean, they have all these systems in place for a $45,000 vehicle that gets abused when they're 35. Yeah.

But their million-dollar health insurance plan is on autopilot. Well, it's hard. It is. It's hard. It's complex.

It's not easy. It's really not a fun thing to do. No, it's built that way. It's not a sexy topic. Yeah, it's not. Yeah. It's not.

It's, it's like ...

It feels like even ...

I mean, I'm sure you guys are experts. I've been in HR for a long time. We work with benefits. It's, like, purposefully complicated, and, like, it just layers and layers year after year. Um, question two. So premiums seem to be climbing. Um- Yeah ... I think we all realize that there was a big ... Most people took a pretty big hit last year in 2025. It's been a hard market, yep. Yeah, it's been a tough market.

So they seem to keep climbing. Um, is there anything a business owner can, like, actually do proactively about that- Sure ... to get ahead of, like, those premiums? Can we talk about that a little bit? Absolutely. Yeah. W- we talked, we talk about this a lot with, with prospects in our client base, but we use the ...

You know, we're, we're sports guys. Right. You know, we use the analogy of offense versus defense. Okay. And I think a lot of employer groups, they're on the defense. Mm-hmm.

You know, they ... You know, even if they're looking at their data, maybe they're looking at it once or twice a year, and they're looking at it almost like reading a report card, like, "This is how we did."

Yeah. Um, where we want you to read it, read your stat- your stats. Mm-hmm. You know? Um, you know, we're just kicked off football season. You know, week one was this week. So many teams right now are in the film room. "Hey, what did, what did the game look like? What was good? What was bad?" There's so many things an employer group can do in the same way- Right ... to review film. And so I, I think a couple things is there is the misnomer out there that numbers are just gonna go up.

And majority of that's true. Yeah. You know? But we have delivered over a dozen zero zeros this year. No way. We have. We- That's huge ... we de- we've delivered multiple decreases this year.

Um- No way. We have. We have. Okay. You know? And because our clients, we feel like going the offensive approach.

Zach said this, and we do- So much education around this in our meetings, it's premiums versus claims.

Yeah. And so many employer groups, all they focus on is the premium piece. Renewal comes out, now it's the battle time, let's just get all our ducks in a row, let's get our pitchforks up and let's go to the carrier- Yeah ... and try to work down the number as much as you possibly can.

Where, but the problem is, is the premium is a reactive factor to your claims.

Right. If your claims are running good, your premium's gonna be good.

And so what our focus is and how you can take control of this if you're a CFO and HR person, you know, looking at your benefits plan is, spend less time looking at the premium number, more time looking at the claim number. Okay. And because if you can control the claim number, the premium number takes care of itself. Mm-hmm. And here, here are some ways to do that. A, look where your claims are coming from. We see this all the time where we're looking at a group, and it's the Pareto principle, 80% of your problems come from 20% of your, of, of your population.

It's probably that way with HR stuff, too. Oh, yes.

And so that's, claims are the same way.

Well, let's say we look at the plan and let, let, let's say most of the claims are coming from a person that they're no- they no longer at your, uh, they no longer work there. Yeah. They're terminated. They left, they retired, whatever else. Let's say the claim comes from a person and they're 67 years old, they should've been on Medicare three years ago. Right, right. You know, let's say it's, it's a, I just talked to an employer last week.

Well, a, over 35% of their claims came from a young daughter who is soon to be 26. Oh. She'll be off the plan in two months. Off plan. You know? Problem solved. Mm-hmm. And so, uh, you have to be aware of those things. And then the other thing is, uh, is think so many, so many employer groups, they just think of health insurance as let's just go get a carrier and let's be done. Right.

There's so many things you can do.

I mean, y- I, I've been doing this for over 10 years now. The job of a broker when I started is wildly different than the job of a broker now. Yes. It's not about just giving you a spreadsheet with four carriers on it once a year. You know, we've got to look at how are employees seeking care. Is telehealth as, uh, an option? Can we shield claims there?

Is it, uh, direct primary care, which is a ever-growing topic. Yep.

It's tiering and steering. Which, which, you know, providers, employer groups, you know, hospitals, you know, whatever, what, where are we getting the best deal? And so how do, how do we get more employees to go there?

So a lot of the story when you're reducing claims isn't, "Well, we just gotta wait for our group to be healthier," and, "Well, JJ, I can't tell my people not to go seek care."

That's, that's not what we're saying at all. Right. We're saying probably go get more care than what you're getting now- Right ... just do it in a smarter way. Because ultimately, if you can reduce that claims number, that's where you're, you get pretty happy with your premium number.

Yeah. Yeah, I think, you know, it's so interesting that you say that because, um, oftentimes people ... It- it's like the BUCAHs, right? Oh yeah, yep. Go get the BUCAHs, that's all there is. Put them on a spread. And, and yeah, put them on a spreadsheet, which one looks the best, what can our people afford? And what I'm hearing you say, and I think that most ... One, it's hard, it's complex, but you guys are taking the time to like customize benefit programs- Yeah, you have to ... for each one of your clients. You have to. 100%, yeah. That's not the norm. Sure. It's so easy, and we work with ... I've done this for, I've done this for over 15 years, and typically it's like, "Hey, you're running fine, just renew it," right? Yeah. "Hey, everything looks okay." Well, fine, but like what we're not looking at, and I think a big part of what we do, is we come in and, and typically, like we have partnerships with like guys like you who want to do this, and they've got a broker that's been their buddy. You know, they were in fraternities together, and that's great- Oh, yeah ... but it's like, they're like, "Ah, just, it looks fine, just renew it." We, you know, we budget 12 to 15% every year. That's standard.

But like why? Why are we not challenging it? And I feel like after COVID, you have things like Curative, TextCare, you know, like people are getting creative about- Absolutely ... solutions for smaller businesses. Yeah. Um, and so what you guys are doing is like, like hearing you talk about direct care, or, um, do, can we, you know, look at this. Or, or may- you're prob- I'm sure you guys do a lot of work with prescriptions, too. Mm-hmm. That's a whole- Yeah ... that's a big old dial to turn. Yep, yep. I'm sure- That's Zach's specialty there. Yeah, is it? Ta- talk to me about the, what you can do there. Yeah, I mean, I think the biggest thing for pharmacy, it's ... I mean, like we talk about, health insurance is a broken industry. Mm-hmm, yeah, it is. Um, and pharmacy's a huge piece of that puzzle. You know, you talk about the BUCAHs, you know, Blue Cross, United, Cigna. They all own their own pharmacy benefit manager.

Right.

And the biggest two ways that they profit, number one is spread pricing. So they buy the drug from a manufacturer for $100, sell it to the health plan for 200, and you get dinged for that $200 claim, which affects your renewal. Right.

The other way that's very hidden is rebates. Yeah, big time. Right. Um, they get the drug, the, uh, drug manufacturer pays Blue Cross a rebate to be on their formulary as a $0 copay, and Blue Cross is making money on that. You don't see that on an MLR, you don't see that on a renewal. You don't see it anywhere. You don't see that anywhere. Um, but they're building in the, uh, those significant margins. So one of the first things that we look at when we're building a customized health insurance plan is say, how can we carve out pharmacy, not affecting anybody's access to care, but just shifting the f- the cash flow of those drugs to where there's no spread pricing. Whatever they get it from the manufacturer is what they're gonna get it. Right. And all rebates go back to the group. Yeah. That's huge, right? Huge. And like, and there's a little bit of employee education, but that's where you lean on your HR team, right? Yeah, absolutely. Because it's just, it's- If you have a partnership with them, yeah ... you have to.

Yeah. And it saves so much money. And usually, I mean, the, the employee's happier too, 'cause they're spending less, right? 100%. Less out of their, their pocket.

Oh, yeah, more convenient, you know? Yeah. I mean, you know, and, and people sometimes don't realize actually the savings that are there. You know- Right ... common, common prescription spend on a health insurance plan is around 33, 35% benchmark.

Mm-hmm. But if, you know, we talk to groups all the time where pharmacy is, you know, 50% of their spend. Mm-hmm.

And all of a sudden you can get rebates back and you can reduce your pharmacy spend by 10, 20%.

I mean, like easy. Right, fast. Snap of a finger. Yeah. It's, it's a easy button to turn.

Super easy. You just need to know, and you need a broker who's proactive enough or, like you're saying, not being on the- That can look at it ... you know, defensive end of it. And savvy enough to do it. It's amazing. Well, and there's, there's vendors out there that know that that's a big problem, and so there's a ton of innovation around it, like international sourcing. Yes. You get a drug from Canada for 50% less, right? There's, uh, government-funded programs where they can get it at $0 and put it in a plan. Yeah, Mark, Mark Cuban Cost Plus Drugs. Exactly. Yeah. And it's, it's, they're all out there.

It's amazing. And can we just like, for our listeners who may not be in HR, not in benefits, who are just employees, getting drugs from other countries is totally safe. It's- Totally safe ... it's okay. Totally, totally legal. Yeah. Totally legal. Yep, happens all the time. There's nothing shady. Yeah, it's, it's ... 'Cause people will be like, "Well, I don't want a drug from," you know- From Mexico or somewhere From Mexico- Yeah ... or Canada. And it's like, guys, guys, it's- Same thing ... it's the same dr- it's the same manufacturer. It's all the same. Yep. Um, okay, excellent. So number three, let's talk about- Sure ... everyone's favorite topic, compliance. Oh, yeah. Um, it's one of those things that owners don't think about until something goes wrong. Yep. Um- We say that a lot ... usually, when something goes wrong, it's rather costly. Mm. Um, and so what are kind of some compliant risks that businesses are unknowingly exposed to- Exposed, yeah ... uh, with benefit programs? Yeah, I think, I think there's a few low-hanging fruit that everybody, the hot ones, right? ACA reporting- Yeah ... right, making sure you're getting that done. Um, you know, Section 125, ERISA and POP documents, making sure that you have those filled out. Those are actually really common that we see folks don't take the time to have a vendor that handles that. COBRA, right? Yeah, COBRA's big. That's a big one. That's a really big one- Yeah ... making sure that you have that in place.

The two that we've s- I've seen at least over the past, you know, uh, six months that I've seen pop up for groups that have had a broker for 10, 15 years, large, larger employers, is, uh, 5500 filings for medical insurance. Please file your 5500s. Yep, and 'cause a lot of folks- It takes two seconds ... a lot of folks say- Yeah ... "Hey, we got it for-"

And it's not if, you miss it ... "We got it for our retirement," right? "Well, you do our 5500."

"Well, have you done it for your medical insurance?" "Well, we don't have to do that." Well, yes, you do. If you have over 100 staff enrolled in a- any product, basic life insurance, health insurance- Anything ... you have to file it.

Yeah. Yep. Um, the other one that is, is we've seen, and we've had shared experience with this, is, uh, not, uh, having the valid waivers.

And so- Right It kills you.

Kills you. It kills you. Get a, get a 226J letter. I had a, I had a client that we had brought on their broker from 2022.

They got a, a letter from the IRS- Oof ... a multi six-figure fine because they didn't have a valid waiver for that individual waiving coverage. Go to the marketplace, get a subsidy, and then you get dinged. And they're like, "What is this letter?" And you're like, "That's why we need you to get waivers. Make sure you hit the declarations." It's so important. Very important, yeah. It's so important. And it seems like all of those things are, if you just put it in your routine, and HR should be doing this, right? Yeah. I mean- Sure ... and you guys, I'm sure you help, right? Yeah, big time. To say, "Hey..." 'Cause there are brokers who are like, "Not my problem." Yeah. Yeah. And then there's brokers who are like, "Hey, guys, it's that time of the year. You need to do your 5500. You need to do this." The waivers are so important, but these are little things that, you know, on the whole, in the, in the whole year take very little time. Like- Yep ... to file your 5500, it's like click, click, click, sign.

You're done. Especially a good payroll system. You're rocking and rolling. Oh, yeah. Easy. ACA reporting, easy, right- Yep ...

if you're, if you're set up.

Um, I know ProLiant does a really good way- Mm-hmm ... an easy way to do that. Absolutely, yeah.

Um, so yeah, just the compliance piece, it's so quick. Yeah. Stay on top of it.

But the c- like the cost of doing it wrong- Oh. Yeah ... it is ... And I know that, um, educate me on this, uh, you know, I know with 401Ks, the, the, there's fines and same thing with Department of Labor issues like- Yep ... I-9.

Um, there's no cap on fines.

Is that the same? S- there are some caps. Okay. Uh, but you know, the challenge is, is you know, there's on average, an employer will have 26 compliance, um, kind of checkpoints throughout the year for their health insurance plan. 26. Mm-hmm. A lot of times HR will get to like three or four pretty quick, and then they start to dwindle. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Um, you know, and the assumption is, "Well, my broker handles that." You know, so many times we hear, we'll take over a group- Yeah ... and we'll say, "Hey, you need to do your PCORI filing." Right. You know, and 'cause the group, uh, their previous broker took them level funded or self-funded, and you know, now it's time to do PCORI, and they, "Well, our broker handled that."

Well, that was an IRS document. Yeah, that's- A- and it's, and it's an extra fee. Yeah. Like, they didn't handle that.

Right. You know? Um, so it's, it's all about staying really abreast to the ever- Yep ... changing market. I said it earlier, the job of a broker's really shifted in 10 years. You know, when we started, you know, we didn't have a compliance department.

Right. Now we, we have a full-blown compliance department. Yeah. We have a director of benefits compliance.

Yeah. Um, we have overlay of a, of ERISA attorneys and people that really monitor our, our book of business with us. Yep. You know, but we have multiple people now that all they do for a book of business is compliance. Yeah. Good, good. You know? And so, um, you know, even things like the, you know, Consolidated Appropriations Act came out a handful of years ago. Brokers are still not doing that. You know, I mean, i- it's been out for what, two or three years? Yeah, three years. You know, and you know, you talk about little things like broker commission disclosures. Right. We ask all the time, "Hey, how are you paying your broker?" "I have no idea." Right. Well, you should be getting a disclosure every 12 months that shows every line you have and how your broker's getting compensated.

Um, and so that, I think that's the other piece about compliance.

It's not sexy. It's- That sucks ... it's tedious. Mm-hmm. Um, it takes that level of detail and attention during open enrollment. It's tough. Well, the other thing is it's changing so fast.

Right. And so you have to have a partner, whether it be like, like an HR consulting firm, a, you know, broker, or maybe it's like a subscription service like Mineral HR, something- Yeah ... just to keep you abreast with the ever-changing market. Yeah. And, and I think that you guys have the same philosophy with your clients that we do, and it's that it is the responsibility ultimately on the business owner, yes. Hopefully. But they're hiring us- Yeah ... and they're partnering with you guys to give them information.

It ... we, we know as business owners, there's 9,000 things in a day, right? Oh, yeah. That fly at us in a million different angles, and we depend on our vendors that we hire, and frankly, spend a lot of money with, to tell us like, "Hey, guys, this is due," or, "You're doing this wrong." Yeah. And it sounds like you have the, the same kind of philosophy on that. Well, well, at the end of the day, like what we say a lot in our meetings are like, when you meet with us, in that meeting, 30 minutes, an hour, 90 minutes, whatever else, like I'm gonna put on the board member hat- Right ... of Moss Consulting. Right. Yeah. And for that 90 minutes, you're gonna get every bit of me. Yeah. You're gonna get my experience in compliance, my ... You're gonna get my experience in benefits.

You're gonna get my experience in hiring and firing employees. Like, I'm a board member- Yeah ... for your company, and I ... that's our responsibility as a board member. Yeah. "Hey, guys, are we filling this hole?" Right. 'Cause you look a little thing like a valid waiver, you know, and, and y- and HR may get flack for that. Like, I don't wanna take guys off the job site, and I don't wanna disrupt business.

Mm-hmm. Well, nothing disrupts business more than 150 doll- 150 grand fine- Right ... from the IRS. Yeah. Yeah. And all it takes is one little slip of paper- Right ... to make it all go away- Right ... and you don't have it. And it's all digital too now. I mean, it's- Oh, yeah ... we've made it so easy, but I, yeah, I think that, you know, it's ... I've come across a lot of brokers in, in my tenure doing this, and there- I would say you guys are the exception. Most brokers are like, "Set it and forget it."

Yeah. "See you, see you in nine months when we go to renew," or like, "We'll go out to the BUCAHs here. You know, looks fine." Yeah. So I think that if you're a business owner and your broker's not wanting to meet with you at least, at least twice a year, but probably quarterly- Probably quarterly, yeah. Mm-hmm ... um, and if they're not providing you a, a number or for, for your employees or for the benefit, uh, like either the benefit department or HR department that they can call you guys or your compliance department, like something's wrong- Sure ... and you should reevaluate I- Yeah ... I think. Yeah. Um, y'all are doing great. Yeah. We're killing it. We're- Cool ... almost, almost there. Uh, open enrollment. Yeah. Open enrollment has a reputation for being a headache for HR. Yep. Super boring for employees.

Mm-hmm. Um, expensive for the business owner.

Yeah. Um, however, I think that if we shift the model, open enrollment's great. It's a great time to get people together. Mm-hmm. Yeah. It's a great time to, like, hopefully deliver some good news or carefully deliver like, "Hey, your premiums are going up," and why.

Yep. Um, so what's changing about the process of open enrollment that you guys have seen? Um, and how do we, like, create a really cool employee experience for one that typically they glaze over in like- Yeah ... 25 seconds? Yeah. Well, I'll, I'll, I'll probably take it first, and you can add on. Yeah. But I, I think number one, at 19:21, um, we've got a great team for this. We actually have built a model around that. We have, we have a director of, of employee experience and employee engagement- Cool ... who is, who really heads up our open enrollment. She's terrific. She's been with us a long, long time. Um, we've got a team that manages technology. We've got a team that manages collateral. Awesome. You know, so I, I think number one is you have to be built for open enrollment. I think, again, that's different. You know, the last couple ... last l- last decade of doing this- Yep ... the expectation is, "Hey, broker," you know, you may not be the head of open enrollment, but you better be pretty involved.

You know, you better be able to speak multiple languages. You better be able to have- Yes ...

material. You better be b- be able to be on site one-to-one.

So I think the broker being super involved helps, uh, hel- hel- helps a great deal.

But I, I think ... I want to answer it in two part. I think A is great technology. Yes. You have to have great technology.

Yes. You know, the day and age of, you know, passing out, you know, papers in, um, in payroll envelopes and then getting it back- Yeah ... the next Friday when they come and get their next paycheck.

She gone. She gone. It's, it's, it's crazy tedious for all involved. It's ... The employee doesn't like it. I don't care what they say.

They don't like it. They don't like it. HR is miserable. Yep. Um, going back to the compliance question, you're setting yourself up for failure there. So you gotta have great technology, whether that be a, like your payroll system.

ProLiant's a great one. There's a ton of great ones out there. Yep. We're big fans of Employee Navigator. Mm-hmm.

Yeah. Um, I l- Love Employee Navigator ... I love all the, all ... everything Employee Navigator is doing and continuing to evolve. Yes. We, we ... Our team just went to their conference in Maryland. Oh, great. And, you know, we ... and, you know, we're getting educated on the next wave of things that Navigator's coming out with. So I think, number one, having terrific technology because it's all about that employee experience.

You know, if, if I can sit down with an employee and the technology piece is right, well, I can now talk to that employee about benefits. Yes. And I can talk to them about the plan that they chose. Was it good? Was it bad? You know, is it right for your family? Right. What has changed in your family? Mm-hmm. What's changed in your paycheck? Because ultimately, if the technology's right, that part is seamless, and now I can actually speak to that employee. And the ... I would say the second part of what makes open enrollment worthwhile is are you enrolling in your plans, or are you teaching? Are you educating your plans? Right. Right. You know, it's one thing to sit down with an employee, "Okay, what do you want? Medical, dental, same as last year? Okay, get out of here." Right.

Well, there's another thing to say, "Hey, I know you said you want same thing as last year. C- can, can we just review that for just maybe five minutes?" Yep. Because I think sometimes an employee may not realize it. You know, let's just say that, um, you know, I, I've got a wife and, and two kids.

I get health insurance. I ... And I, and I'm paid biweekly, and my biweekly premium is, you know, $1,000. You know, um, and I'm paying two, 2 grand a year, $24,000 a year.

Yep. I mean, what other expense in that person's life is as casual?

I mean, you, you- Right ... you deliberate more at your coffee order- Right ... than this $24,000- Yeah ... expense. Yeah. And so we wanna slow people down. We wanna make sure they understand the level of money that they're spending in this moment and helping make sure this is the right plan for them. Right. So. I love that. I think that, um, you know, it ... where we sit as ... And I think in the way that we've both structured our businesses with our clients and their employees, because the employees are i- is our job, right? Yeah. I mean, we, we need to be- They're the end user, yeah ... strategists. We need to be partners with the business owner, but our job is to protect the employees and to have those discussions, and we are like ... We're the conduit between their, their real life out in the world, their fam- what, what matters, right? Yeah. If you ask anyone, "Who do you work for?" They should be like, "My family, my," you know, "my dreams, my ..." like whatever.

Yeah. Well said. A- and to your point, like it's a car. People could buy a car for what they pay in health insurance.

Like, let's slow down and like- Yeah ... and talk about it, and then we need to talk about, i- is the premiums, especially with business owners, when you're considering, you know, what is the demographic of your, of your workforce, and are mo- are they making enough to where if you're gonna set up a, a, a plan and it's cheap, but the deductible's $10,000- Yeah ... for a lot of people, they may as well not even have insurance, right? Yeah. 'Cause they'll never hit that, so- Can't afford to use it ... they can't. So with open enrollment, I think that you're, you're dead on is educating is everything- Yeah ... 'cause it's so confusing.

Yep. Um, and then I've sat through so many open enrollments when we come on with new clients, and we're like, "Okay, let's meet the broker." And a lot of the times open enrollment sparks we need HR help, right? Mm-hmm. So that ... We come in at that time a lot, and we sit through the open enrollment, and it's like so high level that, that brokers l- we live in this kind of world of- Acronyms ... acronyms.

Yeah. And they- Big words ... these employees- Yeah ... don't understand it. They don't understand what ...

E- even c- co-insurance, a deductible- Yeah ... they're like, "I don't know" You know? Yeah. So talk to me about how you kind of like hit the employee population in a way that's approachable. Yeah. Yeah. I think, I think it's a few different ways. I think it's understanding the demographic, right? 'Cause the way you talk to a, you know, nationwide tech company's gonna be very different than we have with an oil and gas company- Yep ... w- with, with- Big time ... folks out in the field.

And so I think it's having a strategy and working alongside the HR 'cause w- we like to say we wanna be an outsource ... We wanna be your outsource benefits department.

And so understanding your demographic- Um, and then providing them with proactive materials, whether that be if you have a Spanish-speaking population- Yes ... let's send out videos, English and Spanish, of educating them on their benefits.

A lot of times we wanna get to spouses, 'cause they're the decision-makers in the process. Yes, yes. Absolutely.

Having them to understand so that way- And they should be 100% It's a huge cost. It's a big deal. Yeah. It's a family decision. How many times, I can tell you, you know, when we sit in front of a, a, a staff member, and he's sitting there and he's like, "Uh, man, I don't know. My wife handles all this stuff. Like, let me call her real quick." And then they're having to make a intense decision over the phone- Over the phone ... to sign up today and get it done, right? Yeah. It's a lot of pressure, a lot of stress.

And so the more proactive we can get that stuff out to them, a good partnership with the HR department.

Yep. And then, you know, when we're sitting down with that staff member, whether it be English, Spanish, meeting them where they're at. Big time.

Right? Yep. "Hey, listen, like, I'm not here to sell you a bunch of voluntary products to raise my commissions.

Like, walk me through..." You know, if you're a 20-year-old, 20, or a 23-year-old, "Hey, this is your first time getting health insurance.

Hey, maybe it makes sense to be a part of this plan as opposed to this plan." Right. "How often do you go to the doctor? What's going on at home? You know, do you have a child that takes high pharmacy drugs?" So understanding that process.

Um, and also we wanna build a relationship with the employees- Big time ... so they feel comfortable calling our office, not a 1-800 number- Right ... to where they can say, "Hey, I'm at the doctor's office. You said that thing about the preventative care. Like, I want to get that done. Hey, I want to go get this handled." Right. You know, "My ID card didn't show up." We want them to feel comfortable reaching out to us to take some of that burden off of HR. Yeah. Yeah. And love that. Love that. Yeah. And it- that is such a good point, too. And can we just talk about Spanish speakers for a second? Let's do it, yeah. 'Cause this is so important. Yep. I'm gonna tell you guys a story, and I think that you, of most people, will love this, uh, and understand kind of the sentiment.

We have a client who owns multiple hotels. Mm-hmm. Okay. Um, we went to San Antonio to do, like, a badge flip, basically, where th- they had purchased the hotel. We had to terminate from one company, bring on- Mm. Yeah ... to another.

Um, so big benefit push there- Yep ... right?

Yep. We, um, of the 120 employees, I think, like, 80 of them spoke only Spanish. Mm-hmm. Okay. Okay? So first of all, they thought they were getting fired and didn't have a job anymore because th- there was no communication. Sure. That's awful.

We, y'all met Yessica at our, uh- Oh, yeah ... at our summit. Yessica was there. She had a line of literally 85 people waiting to talk to her- Wow ... 'cause she spoke Spanish. And they felt heard, and they were like, "Oh, we're not losing our job." Then it came to benefits. Eight people of, like, the 85 were enrolled in the benefit plan- No ... um, which was tough for the company because it- the ratio was so low. And so there was, like, a percentage, right, of, like- Yeah ... and I don't know the specifics of it, but of re- They wanted to be 50%, yeah ... re-rating or something- 10% change ... 'cause they were ... Yeah. 10% change, yeah. And so, um, we had a, we were gonna only do, they, they had planned to only do an English-speaking kind of orientation. We went back after we badge flipped them. They knew they were keeping their jobs. We were like, "No, no, no. We need to have two English and two Spanish-speaking sessions." We went from eight people enrolled, and we explained benefits deeply to them. Mm-hmm. Like, we went from 8 to, like, 48 people enrolled. Yeah. And these are people that enrolled their families, their kids. And we were thinking, w- what were they doing before? They just simply, they didn't have insurance. Yeah. And you're like, "This is sad." You know? Yeah. And so to be able to speak Spanish and to, like, know the demographic and be able to help them, like, you're not just helping the employee. You're helping their children and their family. And you see, like, we've literally seen over the last, like, f- several months that this has happened, less people are calling in sick. L- like, they're utilizing the plan. They're going to the doctor. They're getting preventative care. So it is, like, powerful to be able to talk to employees and educate them on the benefit plan so that they can enroll to a benefit that they're earning and paying for. Mm-hmm.

It was just, it was a beautiful thing. Yeah. Well, it's the, the biggest challenge, too, is, uh, we talk with a lot of employers that may be not be a good fit for, for us, where, "Yeah, we just offer it 'cause we have to. We got to meet ACA. We just offer it 'cause we have to. I don't care if anybody enrolls in it." You know, it, it, it's a challenge. And but you think that that, that line item of health insurance decreases by having eight people enroll into it. Well, the challenge is those are the folks that need it the most and probably are gonna have the highest cost of claims- Yes ... and the rates are gonna be- Right ... you know, not palatable for anybody else to join the health insurance plan.

Right. And so that makes it- That's a death spiral. Yeah, it's a death spiral, right? Right. Racing to the bottom. And real hard to get out of, right? 100%. Like, I mean, it's- It's super expensive to get out of, yeah. Because it's a culture issue. Mm-hmm. It's a, it's a cost issue. And to your point, it's like, it's the people with heart issues and who have had strokes and who might currently have cancer- That have to have insurance, yeah ... have to have insurance. And so that's, that's when you run real hot- Yeah ... like we were talking about earlier. Yeah.

Well, and I think that goes back to, like, our team. We, we have data that shows this. Our first year, so we, we take over a client. We do our open enrollment. We typically increase enrollment by 15 to 20% year one. Awesome. And it's not, I mean, and it is not because of we're these great salespeople. Actually, the people that go out and enroll for us are not incentivized by sales at all. Awesome. You know, w- I love that ... you know, w- like, we want, we, we want them to focus on being a c- consultant.

And so the way our staff is compensated is based on, like, enrollment efficiencies and things that th- we're doing overall for- Smart ... overall for this client.

So, um, so number one, I think that's a big piece. You know, a lot of times employers will say, "Oh, well, we have this voluntary carrier come out," or, "We have this carrier come out and," or they, or the broker hires this enrollment firm to come help.

Well, h- look behind the curtain here.

If you have a carrier that comes out and to, they're there to sell their product.

Right.

You know? And so that's why we own that quite a bit on, like- Love that ... we wanna go in and teach. And you know, you brought up Spanish speakers. It's, it's re- it's, it's everyone.

I mean, insurance is not a very literate language.

No. You know? Um, you know, but we see it all the time where an employee will have a health insurance plan for two or three years. L- let's call it a high deductible health plan. Yep. You mentioned earlier, you know, a $5,000 deductible.

Well, we'll go in and explain to them. We're like, "Oh, this isn't a very good plan." We're like, "Well, it can be, but for your situation it's not." Right. Yeah. You know? You have this chronic maintenance. You have all these drugs. You're, you're having a baby. And you've got to pay 100% of these costs. Until you hit 5,000 bucks. Until you hit 5,000 bucks. He's like, "Well, I want this plan." You're like, "Yeah, that makes a lot more sense for you and your family."

Right. And boom, now in his h- w- prior to that, health insurance at this company sucked.

Right. You know? It, it i- it's a hindrance of them working there.

One edu- one open enrollment education session later, now it's the reason that guy's staying here. Right. Yeah.

You know? And so I, I- The, the benefits are, are endless. Yep. Um, and you, but it does take that, that, that switch from an employer, a CFO and HR person to say, "Hey, we're gonna, we're gonna do this once a year and we're gonna do it right." Yeah, I love it. And I think to, um, to your point real quick on that is, is I, I think it's, like, put in our heads for years, right, that the benefits at my company sucks. They could be excellent, they're just not on the wrong plan. Yeah. And so the education piece is, is key. It is. All right, let's go to question five.

So in this economy, I mean, in this job market, how does a, a strong benefits package actually matter when it comes to attracting and keeping good talent? Yeah. Kind of on the same vein. I, I, I think, you know, there are financial pressures everywhere. Mm-hmm. You know, cost of gas goes up, cost of, you know, a cup of coffee is 2X, to all these things.

And so I think employees more, they're, they're, they're having to do more in protecting their paycheck. Yep. And I think the employers that are taking this really, really seriously and looking at benefits as a, as a tool to attract and retain are the ones that are winning. Yep. You know, we talk to employer, you know, you know, we've got the benefits similar to you, you talk to a lot of employers.

And you'll talk to employers in the same industry, same geographic area, looking for the same employee, looking for the same work, and the employer and their demeanor and their tonality is night and day from each other. Yep. Yeah.

One employer, man, things are great. We're booming. I've got a great team. We're rocking and rolling. And the other one's the sky's falling.

Yep. And a lot of it is your, you know, this is your team, it's your staff, and you know this as the HR person. You're only as good as the people around you. Yep. And I think the more that you can do to invest in those people is super, super important. And, and it, and we see it a lot. You know? We- we'll, we'll look at employee and, and they'll say, "Well, I could've gone here and made, you know, 5,000 more dollars, but I looked at their benefits package, and because I had a great open enrollment session, I figured out that I'm gonna be paying $6,000 more for health insurance over there." Right. "So my take-home pay is actually less here." Right.

And so those are big things for an employees to kind of connect the dots, but it goes to this whole conversation of it all goes back to this huge, huge strategy of what is your relationship with your broker? How are you communicating things to your employees? Because at the end of the day, the employee has to know that you're doing a great job investing the program. Yeah.

That you're doing things that are, that, that's innovative.

Yeah. Yeah, I think it comes to, like, the total, you know, when you talk about HR and retention, like, the total compensation of... You know, we talk to, I talk to, uh, we do a lot of business within the municipality workforce, and they talk about, "Hey, look, I wanna show the investment that we're making in- into our people in comparison to, you know, other municipalities, fire departments, cities within our region."

And when you're able to show like, "Hey, we've invested thousands and thousands of dollars to keep our contributions as high as possible." Yeah. "We're doing these things with direct primary care. We're doing these things with telemedicine."

I think them being able to see that investment from an employer's perspective- Mm ... not only from just a, a cost or a medical insurance, but, like, we are actively trying to solve for this issue.

Yeah. I think that goes a long way as well. I think so too. And you know, i- in the event that employers do have to, if they've ... We had a situation recently where the employer has been paying for the 100% of the employee-only premium. Yeah. They got hit with a 48% increase. The reality was they couldn't- Couldn't do it anymore ... couldn't, couldn't take it. The, now they're paying 75%.

But to the employees that's a huge hit, right? Mm-hmm. But we had to explain to them why- Tell the story. Yeah ... and that you had to tell the story. And once we did, they were fine. You know? Yeah. Yeah. They just needed to know that it's not like, "Oh, these", you know, "cheapskates, the big money at the big co-" And it's like, no, no, no. Yeah. This is a huge, huge cost, and they ended up, they took a loss on... I mean, not a loss, but they were actually ... It, it didn't help, right? It- Yeah ... it, it- Yeah, their, their 75% may have been more than their 100% the year before. Correct. It, it was. Yeah. And, and so, but they, it, when we explain that, people are smart. They understand. Yeah. And they, you know, and you just have to, like you said, tell the story. Well, I, I, I think use the story to your advantage. Absolutely. We, we, we just finished a big open enrollment. It was similar, you're right. Big increase. Employer had, had to make some big changes.

But we took the opportunity to go in and talk to employees about this claims versus premium. Right. And talk about ER usage, and talk about preventative care, and talk about all the tools inside the plan. Right. And, and, and putting some of the onus on the employees- Yeah ... and saying, "Hey, guys." Yes. Like, there are certain things are gonna happen inside your plan. Of course. There's gonna be cancers, there's gonna be babies that go to the NICU, and there's gonna be things, but a lot of the plan can be controlled. And so if you're showing employees that and it's actually affecting their paycheck, they're, they're willing to listen more in that open enrollment cycle. Absolutely.

U- use your, use Telemed. Yeah. Right? Telemed first. What's the difference between urgent care and an ER? I mean, it's, it's basic information that they don't... And they don't know, but once they know- Yeah ... once they're, like, given kind of this, like, the power of knowledge- Yeah. Mm-hmm ... amazing. Yeah. They use it, and then, a- and they, it, they're directly impacted by it. And when they know that, they make the right- Absolutely ... the right choices. Yeah, you're not, if you hit your, we hit it all the time. I hit my deductible or my out-of-pocket max, I'm gonna go stick it to Blue Cross. It's like, you need to understand that- Yeah, don't. Please don't ... you're gonna, just hurting yourself next year. And your coworkers. Blue Cross is not gonna lose.

Yeah.

Right. No matter what, they are set up in this whole- Yeah. They are not gonna lose ... game to win. So let's, let's start wrapping up. This has been excellent.

Um, before we wrap up, um, what type of clients do you best serve at 19:21?

Yeah, I think, I think it's a few things. I think it's less about in- industry size or industry or demographic. I think it's really having an engaged ownership staff that's open to innovation and open to some of the things that we talked about today. I think if you have an HR that takes open enrollment seriously- Mm-hmm ... I think if you have a finance and executive team that's open to innovation and change, different funding mechanisms, different creativity, I think that's where we're a best fit. Where we're not a great fit is when it's, "We're just trying to meet ACA.

We don't want you to come out to open enrollment, and we're never leaving Blue Cross."

Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. It hard to- They, they don't care for change, you know? Yeah. But yeah, to Zach's point, I, I mean, if you're an employer and you're in Denver, Colorado, and you're listening to this and you're like, "Man, I just wanna have a different conversation", like, that's who we wanna strive to meet. Yeah. Every CFO, every CEO, every HR, they event- they hit this breaking point. Yeah. And it doesn't matter that you were in a fraternity with this guy in college, or you go to church with this cat, or- Money talks ... you know, or, hey, you know, I'm in a workout class with this woman. Like- And they, everybody gets this to this point. Yeah And once you get there, that's where Zach and I and our, and our team can be really dangerous in helping you look at, look at this problem through a different lens. I love it. I love it. So tell me, quickly tell me the story about 1921. How'd you start?

How'd you get here? What's, what's the story? Yeah, I mean, really quick, uh, we were on the carrier side, or I- I- I was on the carrier side. Oh, really? Yeah. And, uh, my job was to go into broker houses and, you know, and kind of be that supplemental guy and say, "Hey, look, you know, if you sell more of my product, I'll help you with open enrollment, help you with technology," you know, whatever the pitch was. And what we saw, by far and large, not, not all brokers are like this, if you're a broker listening, don't hate me. Brokers in general are lazy. Um, you know, it's, you know- I think that's true ... rinse and repeat and, you know, let's put it on a spreadsheet and go. And what we were seeing was, you know, an employer that has maybe 500, 600 employees, the strategy they were getting was incredible. Yeah. The tools and the technology and the nuance and the consulting and the data. Well, then you go to 125-life company, and they weren't getting anything. Yeah.

And so, and what we, and, and what we found was, man, we're in Central Texas. We're based in New Braunfels. We have the I-35 corridor. We can get to Austin and San Antonio within an hour each. Man, there are a bunch of solid 100, 150, 200-life companies- Right ...

that don't have the tools and resources that actually probably need that strategy more- More ... than the 500-life company. Yep. Totally. And so we, we, we, you know, born 19:21 Consultants, back in 2020 right before COVID started.

Okay. You know, COVID was a really hard time for, for a lot of employees, a lot of families, a lot of employers. Good time. Yep. Let me tell you, it was a great time to start a health insurance company. I bet. And, um, because it brought health insurance to the forefront of so many conversations. And, um, and we've been super blessed.

Uh, we- we've had a great team. Um, e- we- we've, uh, in our 9 or 10 years, we've never had an employee quit. Okay. Um, so we've been able to grow pretty quickly. Our staff's almost 30 now.

Um- Oh, congrats. Yeah. That's a big number. Yeah. Our, um, you know, our client base is awesome. You know, we were looking th- th- this week, we have a 97, almost 98% retention rate. Mm-hmm. Oh, congrats, you guys. Um, you know- That vital HR heart. Yeah. That, that's amazing. Yeah. You know, but, you know, if you can keep great people inside your four walls and you can keep great clients, it's easy to grow.

Yeah. And so, um, the Lord's been really good to our business. Cool. Uh, we've been super blessed by him and what he's, you know, the rooms he's put us in. Yeah. And, uh, Zach actually came on later. Um, Zach, Zach was a huge addition to our team like four or five years ago now. Mm-hmm. You know, recently moved on the, in, in the partnership seat, so.

Awesome. Yeah. Very cool. So I'm, you know, super blessed to run, run with him every day too.

Yeah, that's awesome. It's amazing. It's, it's fun to grow, and it's fun to help people. Yep. And I think that what you guys have done a really good job of is making... You probably make every client feel kind of like your only client when you're in their office. That's the goal. That's the goal, yeah. You said you put your hat on, your, your board member hat on and, and that's the way that people need to feel cared for, and they need to feel seen, and they need to feel understood and, um, you don't get that a lot from brokers. So congrats, you guys. Yeah, thank you. Thank you. That's amazing.

So for anyone who is listening who wants to get in touch with you, how do they do that? Uh, I mean, you can shoot us an email, uh, you know, zach@1921consultants. We have a, got a good website. You can go on there and check it out. Okay. Uh, phone number.

Yeah, yeah. Fill, fill out the, uh, survey on our website. Fill out the survey. Reach out to you. Reach out to Moss. Yeah, reach out to us. Yeah, hey. We'll connect you. I need, I need help with 19:21.

Yeah, but, um, yeah, please, we're, we're happy to help. Yeah, I think a lot of times too, there, there's a misnomer out there that, you know, we have to be your broker of record to help you. That's not necessarily the case. Yeah. If you're a CFO, HR person, and you just heard something on this today, and you wanna call and ask questions, Zach and I are in it for you. We'll answer them pro bono. Cool. You know, if you wanna do a benchmark, we'll do it pro bono.

If you wanna ask about this strategy or whatever else, we will answer that question pro bono. If you just want- I'm like, we're here to help ... if you just want another set of eyes, I know there's a member of your team that had reached out and said, "Hey, Zach, I saw this. We got this renewal. Like, what would you do here?" Like, hey, let's get on the phone. Let me walk you through it. Here's what I'm looking at. Here's the questions to ask your broker. Yeah. And if they answer it this way, hey, maybe you should look in the market and be looking for alternative solutions.

Yeah. Yeah. That's so rare. Yeah.

Like, just for, for our listeners who may... Like, broker of record is really where people will start to help, and that's like- It's where we get paid ... Yeah, it's where they get paid, and so for you guys to offer that to at least to our clients and our contacts- Mm-hmm ... I can't thank you enough. Yeah. 'Cause that, that is a true gift because it, it is your time and, um, in the, in the world that we live in and the wor- how our business is run- Mm-hmm ... like, time is money. Yeah. So thank you for that.

Yeah.

And, um, yeah- Yeah ... it's, it's been fun to learn our partnership together. You know, and- We'll continue to do that ... and, and we're not trying to fix things that aren't broken. Yeah. We've talked to a lot of HR people and ownerships groups that we're like, "Hey, look, like, you're in a good spot here. You know, you ask these questions, they answered it this way, thumbs up. Keep going." Yeah, and the beauty in that is when it's not, they're gonna call you guys, which is, is the best. 100%, yeah. We hope so. Yeah, it's, you're making deposits, and I think that that's the best. Yeah. You start by giving is that's how we do it too, and it's- Yep, bring value to people. That's it Just continue to bring value to people. Then they'll call you when they need you. Yep. And it's all, it's all organic at that point. Um, guys, thank you so much, uh, for joining us today. It was awesome. If you're listening and you need help building a smarter benefit strategy for you and your team, uh, reach out to Zach and JJ at 19:21 Consultants. You can reach out to them via their website or get in touch with us. We'll connect you. Uh, and if you need help building, managing, or growing your team overall, reach out to Moss Consulting HR Services using the link below this clip. Thank you so much for tu- tuning in to the Moss HR Minute, and we will see you next time. Awesome. Thank you. Awesome. Thank you. Thanks.

About this episode

Your health insurance plan is one of the biggest investments your business makes, yet many owners renew it year after year without asking questions. The right strategy can lower costs, keep you compliant, and turn benefits into a reason people stay. JJ and Zach share what business owners get wrong about their benefits, how rising premiums actually work, and what it takes to make benefits a tool for attracting and keeping great people.

Key topics

  • Why your medical loss ratio is the first sign you may be overpaying, and what "running hot" really means
  • Why auto-renewing your plan every year can cost you, even if nothing seems wrong
  • Why controlling claims matters more than fighting over premiums at renewal
  • How pharmacy benefit managers profit through spread pricing and hidden rebates, and how carving out pharmacy can help

Need help building, managing or strengthening your team?

Book time with Nicole to talk about your HR needs.

Subscribe for New Episodes