THE MOSS HR MINUTE | EPISODE 27
Retirement as a Co-Pilot: Balancing Employer Costs and Employee Value
June 25, 2026 · 16 min 39 sec

Read the full transcript
Hey, everyone. Welcome to this edition of The Moss HR Minute. I am Nicole Moss. I'm the co-founder of Moss Consulting HR Services, where we help business owners solve the people and operational challenges shaping today's workplace. On this show, we sit down with leaders, experts, and entrepreneurs to uncover the real issues that business owners face and how to tackle them with modern solutions. Today, I'm joined by John Alvarez, uh, a retirement plan advisor with IMA Retirement, a firm that helps employers design, implement, and manage retirement plans, benefits, and ongoing compliance.
John has a deep experience helping small and midsize businesses navigate everything from plan design to enrollment to compliance to employee engagement and benefit strategy.
Uh, they do it all. So here's how this show works. Um, I'm going to ask you, John, five, uh, questions that business owners are grappling with right now. Um, you're gonna have one Moss minute to give an answer, so no pressure. Um, that's only 60 seconds in case you weren't sure, and then we're gonna break it down together. So are you ready? I am ready.
Thanks. Thanks, Nicole. Okay, let's, let's go. Um, okay, so John, many small business owners wonder if retirement plans are worth the cost and the administrative burden. From your vantage point, um, what are the biggest advantages for small or midsize businesses to offer retirement benefits, and when does it make sense to start, all in one Moss minute? Well, so one of the main things that you wanna kinda look for as a business owner is steady cash flow. If your company is flowing steadily with cash and you wanna have a better benefit program for your employees, perfect time to look at doing a retirement pro- plan program. Couple different ways to look at it.
Um, it's a talent and retention, uh, tool, help you acquire and keep your employees. As a business owner, it's a great way to, uh, create a little tax advantage savings program for yourself. You can really optimize that as the owner and, you know, put away a lot of money for retirement.
Financial wellness. You wanna have your employees, um, you know, feel that they're prepared for retirement and on the path to retirement because if they are less concerned about that, they're more attentive at work, little bit better production, and, you know, for career pathing and other things like workers' comp rates, it has some advantages.
Uh, as far as when to start, as soon as possible. Uh, you know, kinda like the saying about when the best pl- time to plant a tree, 20 years ago. Yeah. Next best time, today. So, uh, it's never too late, but you wanna go ahead and get that thing started. Okay, awesome.
It... So weird, in your notes we were talking about 8 to 12 employees, so that's 8 to 12 full-time employees. Is that really about the time? Yeah, so if you are, um, kind of in that, in a, in a growth mode or starting to kind of begin growing, 8 to 12 employees is, is probably a good starting point. Okay. Um, mainly because you're starting to look at the differences between something like a SEP IRA or a SIMPLE IRA. Uh, the 401(k) just gives you a lot more flexibility in terms of creating a, a richer benefit program for yourself as a business owner, for your employees, and giving them a lot more flexibility in terms of how much they're able to, uh, contribute to their 401(k) plan. Perfect. I think that was in one Moss minute. Close enough. Okay. I'm gonna give you the win on that one. I think it was perfect. Um- Didn't know it was a contest. It is. Yeah, you gotta do it in one Moss minute. Okay. If you don't hit your minute, I can't tell you... I mean, you'll see. There's no, there's no clock. There's no timer.
I don't know how to- Steve will k- Steve is gonna- Yeah ... he's gonna, like, point at you. We'll call that, we'll call that one a win. Um, okay. So there are many retirement plan options, 401(k), SEP IRA, SIMPLE IRA. Maybe there's more. You can educate me. Um, and each has trade-offs. How should a business owner decide which plan fits their company best? Is it depending on company size, budget, growth goals?
Um, and can you walk us through that in one Moss minute? One Moss minute, here we go. So, you know, a lot of it kinda will come down to the y- you know, complexity, uh, of your payroll process, company size, you know, kind of your, your growth plans.
Mm-hmm. Um, and you have everything from state-mandated programs in, I think, about 17 states currently that- Mm-hmm ... that have a mi- a mandate for retirement plans. Then you have your SEP IRA, SIMPLE IRA, 401(k). Um, you know, the, the, the IRA programs are a little bit easier to administer- Mm-hmm ... lower cost, but they have a lot more restrictions. So like a, you know, a SEP IRA, um, is gonna have employee or employer only contributions. So there is a required contribution for all employees who are eligible.
Okay. You know, can't... There's no employee deferral, so there's no savings for the employees. A SIMPLE IRA allows for, uh, employee salary deferrals as well as a required company match, um, but it doesn't have as much deferral opportunity as a 401(k) plan. So in terms of the most flexibility, the 401(k) is the way to go. But in terms of administrative burdens, the IRA programs, SEP or SIMPLE, are gonna be a lot easier to set up and run for a smaller company. But one thing I like to do is kind of think about it as a more strategic, uh, approach to the, to the retirement program. So instead of just looking at what works now, try to figure out what's gonna l- you know, work best in three to five years for your organization.
Uh, and by doing that, you're gonna go ahead and have a, a much better total rewards program for your employees. Yep, love it. Excellent. Question number three. You're doing very good, uh, better than most, not that anyone has ever done bad, but you're doing excellent. Um, having a retirement plan comes with regulatory re- uh, requirements, non-discrimination rules, reporting, and fiduciary responsibility.
What are the most overlooked risks or compliant pis- pitfalls that small and midsize employers face, and how do you advise them, uh, to avoid trouble in one Moss minute?
The regulatory and fiduciary risk is real. There are definitely areas where an employer needs to put some focus into it. You know, late payroll deposits to the retirement plan, that's a big red flag. Um, missing or incorrect, uh, distribution of annual notices. There are a number of notices that need to go out with a certain timeframe of- Yep ... required. If they don't go out on a timely manner, that causes some compliance issues. If you have a plan design that fails compliance testing, uh, discrimination testing, then you're gonna have money going back to your, your higher earners. You're gonna have corrective contributions, things that, that are administratively, it's a burden, and B, it's a, uh, you know, financial burden. Yep.
Uh, a lot of times the ERISA bond is not sufficient for a retirement plan. You need to have sufficient coverage of the ERISA bond.
Just these are s- small things that are checked off, but they are pretty important in terms of creating that fiduciary best practices for your retirement plan program.
Awesome. Perfect. That was definitely within one Moss minute. Well, if I have a couple seconds left- You do ... I would say that one of the best ways to kind of, um, you know, be proactive about having a plan to, to keep it in, in the, in the rails, if you will, is to engage a good advisory firm that will actually take you through an entire plan governance process, provide fiduciary education, wellness, and education for your employees, and just really, you know, kinda take control or, or tell... help you take that retirement plan program to the next level. Yeah. Can we talk about that for a second? Sure. You bet. Because I, I think you and I have talked before, and I from an HR consulting standpoint, have seen the a- the risk, the headache, and the terror, truly, I mean, it... that comes if you don't have a really good advisory firm. Mm-hmm. And I know IMA is, I think, uh, of working with you and, and learning about you guys, is one of the best. You guys seem to be very proactive. And I think for our small to mid-sized business owners out there, you've gotta partner with people that you trust and who are gonna kinda carry the ball forward.
Um, 'cause, you know, no one's experts, in these fields like you are. Um, so can you talk a little bit about w- what you do with IMA and, and how you guys are, are proactive? Yeah. So our service model is the same for a small startup plan as it is for a, you know, 1,000-employee, uh, plan with, you know, $150 million in plan assets.
Uh, we wanna make sure that from a, a holistic standpoint, every aspect is, is considered; plan design, investment performance, investment expense, record keeper expense, vendor expense.
Um, w- we're gonna benchmark, we're gonna look at everything, we're gonna, you know, peel everything apart, provide a very transparent look at the plan from a very, uh, high level down to any detail that's needed.
Um, we like to talk about ourselves as your retirement plan co-pilot, meaning we wanna sit p- side by side with you- Yeah ... as we get you to that destination for your retirement plan for your employees. One of the, one of the, the key things that we wanna do though, is to help educate that 401(k) committee on exactly what their, their, you know, roles and, and requirements are to run a plan from a fiduciary standpoint, from a plan governance standpoint, and then provide that insight, you know, help with plan design to kinda help them understand, how can we optimize this plan for our, for our, for our organization as well as our employees, and really just, um, you know, make it as, as integral part of the overall employee benefits total rewards program as we can.
Love it. Absolutely perfect. Question number four: Um, competing for good employees is harder than ever, uh, and retirement benefits can make a huge difference. I think we all know that. For small to medium-sized businesses, how can retirement plans be used strategically to attract, sh- uh, retain, and reward people without breaking the bank? Um, sum that up in one Moss minute.
Here we go. One quick minute. So, you know, the, the, the retirement plan strategy does need to, you know, kind of factor in a lot of, you know, pieces of, of what's important for the business, what's important for your employees.
One of the most basic starting points for a 401(k) would be a safe harbor 401(k). Okay. It has a required employer match, but it's kind of capped at a certain amount.
And what that does is allows the, the ownership or the executive team to maximize their contributions without failing any of the, uh, the, the discrim- non-discrimination tests. So it allows for all of the employees to have a really robust retirement plan program with that flexibility.
Um, it'll have Roth contributions, uh, pre-tax. So it really does, you know, allow the employees to have the, the, the full control over how they invest their money.
And there's ways to create a, a reward program within the 401(k) that allows you to kinda reward your top performing, uh, group or your executive team, um, by creating a plan design that, that allows for that and, and is still with- within compliance.
The one thing that we like to kind of help employers understand is that it's not a static thing. We wanna, again, have that three to five year look at how- Yep ... this is a strategic part of their overall, um, organizational total rewards program.
So, you know, we're helping get that to the next level if we can. I, I think it's so important. Um, and it really does help retain employees.
And, and really at a certain point and at a certain employment level, um, the SIMPLE IRA and the SEP IRA could be great, uh, to start with, but I think to your point- Absolutely ... you have to think three to five years ahead because that is quite the transition too- Yeah ... to go from one to a 401(k). Yeah, because when you have the IRA program, you have to unwind it. It has to be, you know, stopped on a plan year, and then there's, you know, these participants that have these assets, they need to roll them into, you know, something else. So it, it can be a little bit of a headache and, and a little bit of a friction point for the employees.
But if you start with the, you know, a simple, you know, basic 401(k) program, that can grow. That can be changed over time to really kinda meet the changing needs of the organization. And one thing I will kind of also add is that, you know, employees v- value the 401(k) plan.
Mm-hmm. It is the second most important piece of the total rewards program for them behind group medical. Yep. Um, and that's, that's, you know, plenty of research shows that. So kinda bridging that gap between the cost for the employer and the benefit for the employee is really the, you know, kind of finding that sweet spot for that employer to, to, to roll out a program that fits for their employees.
Awesome. Follow-up to that really quick because there is, for a small and growing company, the... Uh, and correct me if I'm wrong, but it's much more affordable recently to bring on a 401(k) than it has been in, in years past.
Yeah. So not only is it a little bit more affordable just because of the transparency in, in pricing for the different record keeping, third-party administrators, et cetera, uh, there are some good tax incentives.
So- Any firm that is starting up a plan, there is start-up plan tax credits up to $5,000 a year for three years, as well as im- uh, contribution credits for contributions, matching contributions, profit sharing contributions for the employer, up to $1,000 per employee, with some, some, some caps.
So not only is it more, more affordable just from an overall fee standpoint, there are some incentives from the, the tax code that allow an employer to really take advantage of some, some benefits of, uh, starting up a plan.
Awesome. And then could IMA, you at IMA, or anyone help... Because there's y- you know, in a lot of the places you have, a lot of states you have to pay half of the employ- like, the, um, medical benefit. Right. And then there's the cost of the 401(k). Can you all help them through that, kind of, balancing or figuring out what they can afford? Yeah, so, th- you know, there, there's a m- number of ways to, to have the, the fees for the 401(k) plan established. So some of it can be paid by the employer, some of it can be paid, paid by the plan assets. Mm-hmm. So, um, it just depends on what that need is. There's no regulatory framework says that you have to pay a certain amount of the, the record-keeping fees from, you know, from the employer. So it, it's flexible. There's a lot of flexibility there. Okay. Um, we can help guide them through which providers have that flexibility, say, "All right, we're gonna hard bill for a base fee of a certain amount, then asset-based fee for a certain amount." So there's, there's ways to structure it that, that will meet that employer's needs. Okay.
Great. Awesome. Question five. You're killing it, John. It's one thing to launch a retirement plan, it's another thing to make sure it's used, appreciated, remains compliant as the company grows. What should owners expect in an ongoing management communication, uh, with employees, and monitory, uh, monitoring, and why it matters, in one Moss minute?
One Moss minute. So really, the, the, the shorter answer is that when you hire a, a, uh, an advisory firm that is dedicated to the corporate retirement plan space, um, you should expect a lot of support, a lot of transparency in terms of what you're getting. So from, um, regularly scheduled meetings, investment reviews, fee benchmarking, uh, surveys on, on participant happiness, uh, utilization of the plan. There's a lot of things that we wanna take a look at. Uh, we also wanna make sure that from, um, from an annual compliance process, that the testing goes smoothly, that there's fiduciary training for the 401(k) committee, plan design checkups to make sure that the plan is still meeting the needs of the organization as it progresses down the road. Employee communication's another key area that will kind of drive that success of the plan. If the employees are well aware of how the plan is a benefit to them, that there's ongoing touch points to help them understand the plan, then you're gonna have higher participation rates and, and higher, um, satisfaction, as well as just better retirement readiness for your employees.
And again, when that happens, you see downline effects of better workers' compensation, career pathing is a little bit easier. Uh, your group medical can go down if people are retiring on time. Yep. So there, there's a lot of, you know, benefits that are not just about the retirement plan that can come from a, a well-designed retirement plan program.
Perfect. John, thank you so much for joining us on the show and sharing your wisdom with us. Um, can you tell our viewers what types of businesses do you best serve, when should they reach out to you, and how can they get in touch with you? Sure thing. Uh, and thank you for having me. Of course.
I appreciate it. Um, best type of businesses are, is really any business. Uh, we work with everything from manufacturing companies to professional services organizations, and everything in between. There's really no, um, you know, type of plan we can't work on.
We definitely have a lot of unique solutions depending on your industry, and we can help kind of, you know, create that plan for you. Please reach out at any time. You can find me on LinkedIn, John Alvarez. Okay. Uh, with IMA Retirement. Or you can email me, john.alvarez@imacorp.com.
Awesome. That's great. Everyone, thank you so much for joining us. Please stay tuned for the next edition of The Moss HR Minute. Uh, and be sure to give John a call when you can.
About this episode
Many small and mid-sized business owners see a retirement plan as just another expense. A well-designed plan can do much more: help attract and keep great people, and give owners their own tax-advantaged way to save. John explains when a growing business should move beyond simple options to a 401(k), and what to expect from an advisor who works alongside you.
Key topics
- Why 8 to 12 full-time employees is a good time to rethink your retirement plan
- How a 401(k), SEP and SIMPLE IRA compare on cost, contribution limits and flexibility
- The compliance mistakes that lead to penalties, like late payroll deposits and failed testing
- How Safe Harbor provisions, Roth options and new tax credits (up to $5,000 a year for startup plans) can help you compete for talent
IMAAS is not part of the Moss Consulting Group and does not share views or opinions. This communication is not a solicitation or offer to sell securities or investment services. All content and communication are for general informational purposes only and does not guarantee future performance or success. No cash or non-cash compensation, directly or indirectly, was provided.
Investment advisory services provided by IMA Advisory Services, Inc. (IMAAS), doing business as IMA Retirement. IMAAS is an investment adviser registered under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940 (CRD #112091). Registration as an investment adviser does not imply any level of skill or training. IMAAS is also a registered insurance agency. The oral and written communications of an adviser provide you with information about which you determine to hire or retain an adviser. For more information please visit: https://adviserinfo.sec.gov and search for our firm name.
Need help building, managing or strengthening your team?
Book time with Nicole to talk about your HR needs.