Go Back Up

THE MOSS HR MINUTE | EPISODE 8

Financial Leadership, Compliance and What Growing Businesses Get Wrong About Accounting

with Russ Kimberlin, CPA and Managing Member at Kimberlin Company

March 12, 2026 · 21 min 27 sec

Russ Kimberlin, CPA - Kimberlin Company - Financial Leadership, Compliance, and What Growing Businesses Get Wrong About Accounting
  • 22 min
Russ Kimberlin, CPA - Kimberlin Company - Financial Leadership, Compliance, and What Growing Businesses Get Wrong About Accounting
The Moss HR Minute - Test Import
Play
Read the full transcript

Hey, everyone. Welcome to this edition of The Moss HR Minute. I'm Nicole Moss. I'm the co-founder of Moss Consulting HR Services, where we help business owners solve people, uh, compliance and operational challenges every single day. Uh, we're recording from Phoenix today, and I am joined by Presley Dusenberry, our Phoenix area HR manager, who works directly with business owners across the valley. Today's guest is Russ Kimberlin, who is a CPA and the founder of Kimberlin Company out of Chandler, Arizona.

Russ works with business owners on audits, financial reviews, uh, compilations, and employee benefit plan audits to include 401(k) audits that many companies don't realize they need until it's urgent.

Uh, Russ helps businesses understand what their numbers actually are, what stakeholders expect, and how to stay compliant as they grow. Um, so Russ, here's how the Moss HR Minute works.

We are gonna ask you five very hard-hitting questions, okay, uh, that business owners are dealing with right now, and for each question you get one Moss minute to answer, and then after the one minute, we can dive in, um, and Presley, uh, will ask you some follow-up questions, and we'll go deeper if we need to. Are you ready? Totally. Okay, question number one.

Um, many business owners assume audits are only for public companies. In one minute, what are the most common triggers that cause a private business, uh, to suddenly need an audit? Um, and you have one Moss minute. So the two main reasons I can think of is a loan with a bank. So- Sure ... Joe's Tire Shop, right? Joe starts a tire shop. He needs a loan from the bank. Bank says, "Okay, we're gonna give you money. Um, we wanna see your financial statements. And by the way, we don't trust you. We want a CPA to do those financial statements." Sure. That's one reason.

Um, bonding is the other reason. So like if you work with the government and you're doing, like, construction type work, you ha- need to have your jobs bonded, and so when you do those bonding, you need financial statements to support that. So those are the two main reasons you do regular financial statement audits. Okay.

Awesome. Russ, what happens when business owners, uh, get it wrong or, like, they wait too long to find out that they need an audit? Uh, there's, um, there's two, two things I guess that could happen. Y- y- you could face fines, penalties from whatever regulatory body it is, or if it's a loan, they could simply cut the loan off and- Mm ... and call it due.

So those are your, like, worst-case scenarios. Oh, they could cut the loan off and say, "Hey, the, the entirety of the loan is due"? Lo- yeah, loan's due. And what happens ... So that, that's actually a really important point I think to dive into that business owners probably don't know. What happens if that loan is due and they don't have the cash to pay it? Uh, it's called Chapter 11 bankruptcy. Oh, really? That's- Oh, okay ... that's how they go right to bankruptcy? Yeah. Oh, okay. Well, I mean, that, that could lead to that. Okay. That's, that's basically what happens, yeah. That, so that's really ... I don't think that most business owners, especially ... Like, we deal with companies that have, like, 500 employees or less, and I don't think that they're really thinking about that. Yeah. So if you get audited and the, the financials don't add up, the, the bank could recall or call the loan due?

Y- and the, and the bank ... I mean, it, it doesn't usually get to that point. Okay. Banks know what they're doing. I mean, when they lend money to somebody, they're, they're seeing what's in the bank account. So they have their own checks and balances to, to monitor that. That's just kind of worst-case scenario. Got it. Got it. Okay. Okay.

Interesting. So, like, from a business owner perspective though, they hear audit review compilation, they assume they're all interchangeable or the same thing or maybe they don't even know the difference. So in the one Moss minute, how should an owner decide which level of assurance that they would actually need?

Um, if I'm a business owner and I find out I have to provide financial statements to, uh, to the bank, I'm going to fight for everything outside of an audit. Uh, the audit is the worst. I mean, that- Mm ... the audit is where they come in and they do the most work, and if it's your first time, you really don't wanna go through an audit on your first one. I would say a review is going to be, like, your best-case scenario to get reviewed financial statements because you're still providing footnotes to the financial statements, statement of cash flows. You're still providing pretty much everything that you will be providing in an audit. It's just the approaches in doing that are very different on the review side. So yeah, I would always encourage a business owner to fight for a review or a compilation over an audit. And how would you fight for a review?

Uh, just make really good friends at the bank. Okay. And, and actually, or just make sure your, your numbers are tight. Okay. Like, make sure you're doing the right thing. You know, you've got payroll people. You've got someone in accounting that's doing billing and, and AP. And so I would say, you know, it- don't try to do it all yourself. Make sure you've got some other people in places that'll keep you in check.

Okay, got it. So Russ, a lot of growing companies don't realize that their retirement plan may require an audit. Um, so, and, and a lot of the time, like it's, it's not, it- it's, it's not based on it's doing something wrong. It's based on triggers, right? Yeah. And I think that those changed in 2022 last? Yeah, 2022, 2023. Yeah, they changed from, uh, eligible participants to the account balances. Yep, yep. So in one Moss minute, when does a business become subject to that 401(k) audit, um, and what are the risks, uh, that come with ignoring it in one Moss minute? Um, okay. So the trigger for the 401(k) plan audit is 100 account balances. So, um, if you've got balances in that plan over 100, and that means people that have left the plan and still have their money in the plan- Mm-hmm ... they count as account balances. Uh-huh. Right? Mm-hmm.

So the DOL makes you go through an audit every year, and that audit is due July 31st or October 15th. And so if you ignore those, you get letters, nice letters from the DOL that say, "Hey, we need you to get your, your 401(k) plan audit done." Awesome. Got it.

Yeah. All right. Sounds great. No, so, um, and I think that that's something that growing businesses, y- you, you think you have, like, an HR person who's in- administering the plan, right, and working with the TPA.

Uh, for our viewers that don't know, TPA is third-party administrator, um, which is often you'll hear names like Principal or Voya is one, um- Fidelity ... Fidel- Fidelity ... yeah. So they will send you this l- long list of things that they need, and you have to fulfill those. Um, and it's totally normal. I think people hear the word audit and they freak out.

Yeah. Um, it's, it's fi- it's just pretty standard stuff. Sweet. Good. From, like, an HR standpoint then, where do benefit plan audits usually uncover, uncover problems first?

So, in, and I'll take, like, a first, first-year audit, your, the, the majority of the things that we find are delinquent contributions. So when you take money out of people's paycheck, you have a certain amount of time to get the money back into the plan.

Um, typically on a first-year audit you'll find, you know, Betty in payroll was gone vacation, and so the money was taken from people's paychecks on Friday, it didn't get there two weeks later.

And so that's usually the, the, the biggest thing that you see. The other thing is, um, employee, like, honoring employee elections. So employee, you know, Joe, he, he elects 3% to go into his 401(k) plan and, and 2% is going in instead. It's, it's some of those little things that, that usually are uncovered during an audit. Um, there's a reason that plans under, or companies under 100 account balances don't go through audits. It would be a, it would be a mess. It would be a lot. So typically when you get over 100, you've got a sophisticated HR, payroll, and so those procedures hopefully are in place. And a lot of that is pretty, it's administrative, right? And so you can go back and, uh, the point of the audit through a private company like you is to fix that before it gets reported to the Department of Labor, where they really have to step in. And there's a big difference between the audits that you and your team do versus a Department of Labor audit. Can you talk about the difference between both? Yeah, absolutely.

Um, so with the Department of Labor, like, if they, if they actually come in and do an audit, they're usually pinpointing on exactly where an issue is, whereas our requirement is, you know, once you go over 100 account balances, they want us, it's more of a compliance type thing. Mm-hmm. Uh, I've always said this, that a 401(k) plan, like, when it starts as a young, say, business owner, moving through time, y- your quarterback for that 401(k) plan should be your investment advisor. Hopefully you have a good investment advisor, 'cause they're the ones that hire us.

It's not usually the client that hires us, it's the investment advisor. So a good investment advisor will, will find us because we are the cheapest and, and typically the best service, and so that's why we work so well, like, with the investment advisors.

Um, I, I might have got off track a little bit on that one. No, that's perfect. Just the difference between, it, just it being a, it's a, a yearly compliance review audit- Yeah ... that you all are doing. And I know, I don't wanna interchange the word review and audit, 'cause those are two different things that we just learned, but there's a, a yearly audit that if you have over 100 participants, and that's not employees, that's participants in the plan, that you have to go through this series of, of checks and balances basically that your team would send to, to a, a business and they check them off.

And then if it, it goes to a Department of Labor audit, that's where it's more pinpointed and a little more serious. Yeah, absolutely. And, and the Department of Labor actually audits us as CPA firms as well. So we get audited. It's, it's very random. It's, like, every three years they'll pull us, and they basically audit the auditors to make sure that we are doing the right things. That's usually where they'll start.

Okay. Gotcha. And that's really, oh, interesting, they audit the auditors. Yes. Yeah. That's why the auditors are so- Yeah ... picky about what, 'cause y'all are getting audited too. Which is good. It's good. You're taking people's money out of their paychecks. Oh, that's wonderful, yes.

You're putting it yeah, as the person- Can't wait for the next one. Yeah. When is it? If you, I'm in one right now, it's great.

Um, what do buyers or banks kind of look at when financials aren't audit-ready? Um, I think what they're looking for is, uh, if, are the accounting records being maintained on a, on a, on a consistent basis?

Okay. I think that's what they're... Uh, are there, um, are there, they're usually, they're called controls, internal controls there. Mm-hmm. Are the controls in place to make sure that the numbers are being re- reported correctly?

And if, obviously, I think the first part about that is the fact that the audit's not getting done, um, that's usually what they'll step in and say, "We're not comfortable lending to you." Sure. Yeah. Sure, that makes sense. How do audits then and, like, a clean financial reporting affect a company's ability to either grow or sell maybe? And can you give that in one Moss minute?

Um, to sell is, like, so, so a, a, a business owner who's really thought about, "Hey, I, I want to sell in, say, five years"- Okay ... and goes out and has audited financial statements for five years, even reviewed financial statements over a five-year period, when they get to that, into that five years, the ability to sell that company is so much better than even a company that's doing maybe better financially.

If there's no support behind that, that, like, the support that this person has on a review or an audit financial statement, it's, like, night and day. Um, yeah, 'cause they're gonna, they're gonna have to go back and do it anyway.

Got it. So Russ, from the business owner perspective, what advice would you give someone who wants to stay ahead of audits, be compliant, avoid financial surprise? Um, what's your best advice, in one Moss minute? I would say take your accounting function seriously. So, um, y- a lot of times business owners treat the accounting as, like, the second tier of the business.

"So we're not really gonna think about it until the end of the year when taxes are due, and then we're gonna throw it all together." I would say hire a good accountant that is hopefully internal. If not, hire a good bookkeeper on the outside. But e- but the, the billing, the AP, the payroll, you're gonna need someone for all of that. Um, and then as you grow, if you've got that, if, if that's something you've taken seriously from the beginning, as you grow, y- your growth is, is much easier when you do that. So yeah, that's what I would do. Awesome.

If someone's looking for a good bookkeeper or accountant, what are some things that would trigger or tell them that they're a good one? Are there things that they would say or things you'd see on their resume that would say that they can do these things that you're saying well? I would say m- if you, if you're gonna hire someone, I would, I'd say get their references. Um, see who they've worked with, what types of companies they've worked with.

Um, you do get a lot of people that say they can do that, and a lot of times it's just entering the numbers into QuickBooks, but not really ex- In the right spots, if that makes sense. Yeah. So I would say check the right boxes.

Okay, cool. Excellent. And, and I think there's a difference between... You just made a really good point. That there's a big difference between, like, a data entry position- Yeah ... that's not really an accountant or a bookkeeper, and then there's a bookkeeper who has an accounting background, and they, like, they have a degree in accounting. I think people use the terms interchangeably- Yeah ... and they're really not. Yeah. So that's where you have to differentiate. Yeah. And a lot of the times we see people on the payroll side, we run a lot of payroll for people, and, um, there's a lot of crossover between HR and, and accounting as well, and so the reports of, like, where the payroll goes into the GL really matters, and we've had situations where the GL wasn't mapped from the payroll system, and that's a mess. They're either entering it manually or making mistakes, or it's mapping it to the wrong place, um, which is an interesting, interesting issue that takes a really long time to solve once, at the end of the year when you're like, "Oh, my gosh, we gotta do this thing." Doing all over.

Yeah. So Russ, tell us about your company. What started, what got you into starting it as a CPA, and- Ooh ... how'd you... Tell us, tell us your story.

Yeah, so, uh, I grew up in Flagstaff, graduated from Northern Arizona University, started with a, a s- a large firm. Mm-hmm. Went to work for a local firm. I worked there for about 10 years here in, uh, Tempe, and in 2012 I decided I could probably do this by myself. So I went, and I had 15 401(k) plans, and I started the business, and, uh, several tax firms that were out there really didn't wanna do audits and reviews anymore, so they came and said, "Hey, can you take on some of this audit review work?" And it just kind of started to grow. What's really grown over the last, say, six years is our 401(k) business. We went from w- when I started with 15 401(k) plan audits, we're up to between 250 and 300- Wow ... 401(k) plans. And so that's the piece that's really grown, and, and I think, uh, the employees, we're up to 17 employees now.

Um- Congrats. Yeah, so, so that's, that's been pretty cool to see, I think. I never realized that that piece would grow as, as much as it has. I figured it would be more the audit review compilation, and it's been more the 401(k) plan. But you do all of it? Yep. No tax work, but yes. We're, we're basically an audit shop. Got it.

Um, can you talk through, for a lot of our business owners, there's this new very cool 401(k) option, like, pooling 401(k)s. Can you talk about that a little bit?

Oh, yeah. Uh, so it's called PEP, right? Um, so there's MEPs and there's PEPs. Uh, you're gonna- Okay ... you're gonna have to stop me on this, 'cause I can, I can go wild with this. So multiple employer plans, those are MEPs. PEPs are pooled employer plans. Okay. So, uh, the MEP option has kind of always been around. It's, it's like kind companies, your doctors, your physicians, and they get to basically use the same 401(k) plan, which allows for them to save in costs. The PEP option came out about '21. So I think, what I really think is that a bunch of investment advisors got together and lobbied to try to get this option put out there, and what's happening is, is now you've taken all these different types of companies that can now pool their 401(k) plan together and save on costs.

So if, like, you've got 10 plans that are going through audits, now you get to save and it's just one audit, right? Well, let me, like... So that's the good side of it. What they don't think is you take, uh, a sophisticated ABC manufacturing, right? S- uh, they've got a sophisticated payroll, sophisticated HR, and then they team them with Joe's Tire Shop. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. And Joe is changing the tires, and he's doing the payroll.

Mm-hmm. And he's got a mess. So when you go to audit that- Oh. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So now you see this whole PEP option is not necessarily the best thing. So if you're thinking about going into a PEP, you should really look at who's in that PEP before you join. Oh, they'll let you know who's already in there. I, I would absolutely ask that person- Wow, okay. That's cool ... the same.

Who's in this PEP before I join that, because you've got advisors out there right now running rampant, throwing any Joe Schmo- Yeah ... plan into this PEP. And last year, the DOL, uh, because we called it, we had a, what, this one PEP that's a total mess. I won't take up too much time. But the DOL, I, I have really good relationships there. When, when they're auditing you, you should make really good relationships with them. Yeah. Uh, so I, I asked him, I said, uh, "Hey, this is kind of what I'm seeing on these PEPs.

What are you seeing?" Last year we had a 45% rejection rate on 5500s- Oh, no ... on PEPs. That's crazy. So that's just kind of something to think about. 45%?

Yeah. Oh, yeah. That's- They just, they don't file time, like, they're not typically ready until the September, October timeframe. Oh. Then they're late. So our, October 15th. So it's, it's a, it, we're trying to figure out the kinks right now with them. I think there is a space for them- Yeah ... going forward, but right now it's a bit of a mess. Interesting. So that's really important to know that business owners can be like, "Who's in my pool, what kind of companies?" And they can do their own research. Honestly, if I'm a business owner and I've created something and it's working really well, I don't wanna be teamed up with someone else. Le- let me keep my plan, um, standalone. Is there a time when you would recommend a PEP, like, if they only have a couple employees, or is there a time that it would be advantageous even though you could get in with Joe Schmo? If you did only have, like, a couple of employees and you were teamed up with a bunch of other... But remember, once that plan goes over 100 account balances, you're subject to an audit. Yeah. So a, a startup business, like I said before- Why do it? Yeah ... there's a reason plans under 100 account balances don't go through audits. They would be a mess. Yeah.

Interesting. The, so yeah, if you're under 100 count- account balances, and if you... A lot of companies know, like, "I'm not gonna get..." We likely will not have 100 employees, right? Um, a lot of companies know that they likely won't have 100 employees, so to go into a pool automatically puts you in that pool- Yeah ... that you have to get audited- Yeah ... so you may not need to. Right. Interesting. That's, that's, um... Because they really, these guys are really pushing the pools. Oh, yeah, yeah. The, there's, so there's two types. There's some investment advisors that are gung ho on, on pooled employer plans, and then there's some that aren't. And then the ones that even are gung ho on PEPs- Are still being denied from business owners that are like, "Hey, we wanna stay separate." Like we, we... So you're still gonna have that separate, you know, 401(k) plans where they don't want to go in there.

It's, it's that, um, and I want you to think about this. Investment advisors, they didn't go into business to not make money. Right. So are the PEPs really cheaper, or- Oh ... are they getting paid really well? That was my next question, is do they get- So- ... a kickback? ... something to think about i- with a, an advisor who's pushing PEPs t- really strong, what's the ulterior mo- motive? Right, because if they have a guy that they're running a 401(k) for that has 15 employees, they wouldn't have to go through that. Right. And t- but now they do. Yeah, and I think that that's a good point for business owners. We were talking about this with someone the other day, on, on benefits, like benefit brokers, and any time that we go in and we do an integrity check, we look at, we look at the 401(k) and we look at the, um, employee benefit plans, and you look at the broker. And you go, you know, a lot of the times people will be like, "I've been with this 401(k) guy for 15 years. I love him. He's my best friend. We go on cruises together."

Great. How much is he charging you? "I don't know. It goes with the plan." Or same thing with employee benefits is they're like, I'm like, "How, what's... You're getting an increase every year," and this last year business owners felt the, that, the, um, bene- the employee benefits like the healthcare go up- Oh, sure ... drastically. We had an employ- an employer that went up 48%, cost him 800 grand. That's huge. Yeah. But the broker is a, th- they, everyone's trying to make money, and I'm not trying to say people shouldn't make money at their jobs. That's what we're all here to do.

But the, you're misaligned a lot of the times, and so that's a really good point, that if someone's pushing you towards something that doesn't really make sense or you otherwise wouldn't need to do that. Is that something that people can call and ask you about?

Uh, I would direct them to probably the right advisor. Okay. Yeah. Interesting. Um, Russ, this has been awesome and very helpful. Um, audits, financial reviews, and benefit plans compliance are areas that business owners, uh, frankly often avoid until they, it's like a have-to-do kind of a thing, it's urgent.

Um, and by then the stress and the cost is probably much higher than just staying ahead of things. Um, thank you for joining us and, and kind of breaking this down so clearly.

If you want to learn more about the crucial work that Russ does and hear more about how he and, uh, Kimberlin Company can, uh, help your business, where can we find you? Um, Russ@KimberlinCompany.com Excellent. And if you're a business owner who needs help stabilizing your team, strengthening your HR systems, uh, and making your business less owner-dependent, uh, visit mossconsulting, uh, .com and book some time with our team, and we will see you on the noct- the next Moss HR Minute.

About this episode

Many founders don’t think about their financial systems until something goes wrong. Strong reporting and audit readiness can decide whether a company is able to grow, secure financing or eventually sell. Russ shares what he’s learned in more than two decades of advising growing businesses, and how owners can avoid costly mistakes by staying ahead of their finances and compliance.

Key topics

  • Why audited or reviewed financial statements can make a company much easier to sell
  • What happens when businesses wait too long on audit requirements, and how lenders and regulators can react
  • What business owners should know about pooled employer plans (PEPs) for 401(k)s before joining one
  • Why building strong financial processes early helps companies grow and secure financing

Need help building, managing or strengthening your team?

Book time with Nicole to talk about your HR needs.

Subscribe for New Episodes